A recent family gathering took an awkward turn as a decades-old rumor resurfaced during a conversation between two famous sisters. The exchange, captured for a reality television audience, centered on a sensitive topic: the paternity of one of the siblings.
The incident occurred as the sisters examined a recovered family heirloom—a bible that once belonged to their late father, Robert Kardashian Sr. The book had been gifted to former football star O.J. Simpson during his 1994 murder trial and was recently reacquired at an auction.
While discussing the bible, the sisters began to joke about persistent, unverified claims that Simpson, not Robert Kardashian, is the biological father of the younger sister. The elder sister quipped that the bible’s provenance was “questionable” between the two men, to which the younger sister replied, “Both of my dads – give it to me!”
The most notable reaction, however, was the lack of one. Their mother, present at the table, remained conspicuously silent throughout the entire exchange, offering no comment or visible reaction as she focused on her phone.
The moment was extended when another family member entered and, unaware of the context, asked about handwriting in the bible. The younger sister attributed it to “my other dad’s – O.J.’s,” prompting a startled response from the newcomer.
These paternity rumors have circulated for years. In the past, the mother has vehemently denied ever having an affair with Simpson, calling the claims an “absolute lie.” Simpson himself has also publicly denied being the father, stating he never had a romantic relationship with the children’s mother.
The recovered bible, intended as a sentimental gift, instead became the catalyst for a public airing of a private family rumor, leaving a palpable silence in its wake.
