While the 2025 Critics’ Choice Awards celebrated the year’s best in film and television, a different kind of conversation unfolded online, centered on several high-profile fashion choices that divided audiences.
The red carpet at the Barker Hangar in Santa Monica saw a mix of bold statements and ensembles that sparked more debate than admiration. Among the most discussed was a dramatic, cage-like gown with floral embroidery, which some online commentators likened to a “tumbleweed,” while others questioned the styling direction entirely.
Another look, described by viewers as a “mess,” drew sharp criticism for its perceived impracticality and confusing design, despite the wearer’s significant victory in the Best Supporting Actress in a Comedy Series category. A sheer, ruffled creation also faced scrutiny, with detractors labeling it “ugly” and “weird.”
The evening wasn’t without its sartorial praise, however. A striking, sculptural black dress was favorably compared to another attendee’s simpler, strapless blue-and-black outfit, highlighting the subjective nature of red carpet fashion. Meanwhile, a tailored, business-influenced suit prompted a split reaction, with some applauding its sophisticated detail and others finding it an ill-fitting choice for the glamorous event.
Adding a dose of casual flair, one attendee made a statement by pairing a vibrant pink gown with matching sneakers, a move that certainly stood out among the sea of heels. Another bright, one-shoulder orange gown also captured attention, with critics focusing on the bold color choice while acknowledging the performer’s acclaimed work.
The event proved that on the red carpet, as in art, reception is never guaranteed, and even A-list celebrities can find their ensembles becoming the subject of intense public scrutiny.
